When a Second Copy of a Game Makes Sense

The game is out of print, the price is climbing, and a small voice suggests buying a spare before it disappears. Or the group has started meeting at two different houses, and the box is always in the wrong one. Or the miniatures are finally painted, and now nobody wants to touch them during a game.

Each of those is a real reason to own a second copy. Each is also a reason to spend money on a box that may sit unopened for years. The second copy is one of the easiest purchases to justify in the moment and one of the hardest to evaluate honestly, because the need is usually about a situation rather than a game.

The useful move is to separate the situations that genuinely call for duplication from the ones that only look like they do, then count the costs that never appear on the price tag.

The Difference Between a Spare and a Duplicate

A spare exists to solve a specific problem. It lives in a second location, travels without risking the good copy, gets painted while the other stays playable, or goes out on loan without the owner worrying about the box. You can state the job in one sentence.

A duplicate exists because the game is good and the price seemed reasonable. It sits on the same shelf as the first copy, in the same room, and does the same work. That is not a crime, but it is a collection decision rather than a practical one, and it should be judged by the standards of a collection: space, money, and whether the game will actually be played twice as often.

The one-sentence test is the whole framework. If the sentence is hard to finish, the purchase is probably duplication wearing a practical costume.

Two Locations, One Collection

Splitting a collection between two homes is the clearest case for a second copy. If you spend part of the week in one place and part in another, hauling a heavy box back and forth is a sure way to damage it, forget it, or stop playing it. A copy that stays put removes the friction entirely.

The decision is easier if you sort games by role. Some games are the default opener wherever you are. Some are big-event games that only make sense at one location because that is where the table and the group are. Duplicate the defaults and the travel-friendly titles, not the giant boxes that get played twice a year. The guide to storing games in a small apartment is useful here, because two small collections require two sets of storage decisions.

Be honest about the second location's social life. A second copy at a holiday house that hosts one game night a year is a donation to the furniture. A second copy at a place where you actually host weekly is a tool.

The Travel Copy

Travel is the second classic reason. A game that goes to a café, a convention, or a friend's cabin will get bumped, spilled on, and occasionally left behind. Taking the expensive copy is a risk that grows with every trip. A cheap travel copy absorbs that risk.

The best travel copy is often a different edition rather than a second identical box. A smaller-box edition, a lighter card game in the same family, or a print-and-play version can fill the role without duplicating shelf space. If the game only exists in one large format, a second copy of that format is a lot of luggage for the benefit.

There is also a simple alternative: take a game you would not mind losing. Most collections contain a few titles that are fun, replaceable, and not especially precious. Those are the travel games. Buying a second copy of a favorite to protect the first is reasonable only if the favorite is genuinely the thing you want to play away from home.

Out-of-Print Editions and the Fear of Loss

Out-of-print games create the strongest urge to duplicate. The logic is sound as far as it goes: if the game cannot be replaced, a spare protects the ability to play it after the first copy wears out. The problem is that most spares are bought years before the wear happens, and the money sits in a box in the meantime.

Before buying a spare of an out-of-print title, ask what usually fails. Cards wear, boards warp, and a single missing token can stop a session. Those are component problems, and a spare box is an expensive way to solve them. A better sequence is to protect the copy you have, photograph the components, and buy a spare only if the game is both a favorite and genuinely irreplaceable. The guide to protecting game components covers the cheap interventions that make a spare less necessary.

Collector logic, one to play and one to keep, is a different hobby with a different budget. It is fine to collect, but do not confuse it with insurance.

Painting, Customizing, and the Working Copy

Miniatures games have a practical duplication case that has nothing to do with travel. Paint takes time, and a painted army is fragile in a way that an unpainted one is not. Some players keep a painted set for display and a second copy for actual play, especially when the paint job is elaborate or the models are fragile.

That approach makes sense for a dedicated painter with a game that sees regular table time. It makes less sense for someone who is still learning to paint. The first set will improve, and the second copy may end up as a shelf of half-finished experiments. Start with one copy, paint it, and see whether the fragility problem is real before buying another.

Customization follows the same logic. Rebased models, printed tokens, and painted boards make a game personal, and personal components are harder to replace. If the customized set is the one you play with, a plain second copy can be the lending or travel version. The beginner's guide to painting miniatures is the place to start before committing to a second box.

Lending and the Social Cost

Lending is a generous reason to own a second copy, and a complicated one. If you lend a game you cannot replace, you are trusting the borrower with something more valuable than its price. A second copy lowers the stakes: the good one stays home, the loaner goes out.

The social side matters more than the logistics. Borrowers often feel obligated to return a game quickly, even when they have not played it. A damaged component can strain a friendship if the owner cares more than they let on. Having a designated loaner copy makes the transaction easier for both people, because the stakes are clearly lower.

Track loans somewhere visible, whether a note in a phone or a label inside the box. The unwritten rules of board game etiquette apply to both sides: return promptly, report damage honestly, and do not lend a game you would resent losing. A second copy is not a substitute for that conversation.

The Real Cost of Duplication

The price of the second box is only the first cost. It also consumes shelf space, may need its own sleeves or insert, and ties up money that could buy a game you do not own at all. If the second copy lives in another home, it needs a place to live there too, which is a separate storage decision with its own furniture and climate considerations.

There is an opportunity cost that is easy to miss. A collection of forty games with ten duplicates is really a collection of thirty distinct experiences. The duplicates may be justified, but they are not adding range. The guide to the hidden costs of storage makes the point that space is the line item that keeps charging after the purchase is forgotten.

A simple check: if the second copy disappeared tomorrow, would you replace it at full price? If the answer is no, the copy is probably not doing enough work to justify its shelf space.

Proxies and Print-and-Play as Alternatives

Sometimes the problem is not the whole game but a few components. A missing card, a lost token, or a worn board can be replaced with a proxy or a print-and-play file rather than a second box. For out-of-print games, fan-made replacement files are often the only affordable option.

Proxies work best in casual settings. In organized play or tournament settings, the rules usually require genuine components, and it is worth checking before showing up with printed cards. In a home game, a proxy that is clearly distinguishable from the original can actually cause the same information problem as a marked card, so match the back and feel as closely as possible.

Print-and-play is also a way to test before duplicating. If a free or low-cost version of the game exists, try it first. If the group plays it enough to justify the real thing, buy one copy rather than two.

A Decision Rule for the Second Copy

Use these questions before buying another copy of a game you already own.

  • Can I name the job in one sentence? If not, it is a duplicate, not a spare.
  • Does the second copy live somewhere different? Two locations is the strongest case.
  • Is the game irreplaceable? Out-of-print status raises the stakes but also the cost of being wrong.
  • Would I pay full price again? If the answer is no, the copy is not earning its space.
  • Is there a cheaper substitute? A proxy, a print-and-play file, or a different travel game may solve the problem.
  • Where will it be stored? Name the shelf, not just the room.

The bottom line: buy a second copy when it does a job the first one cannot, and buy it for a game you expect to keep playing. Otherwise, put the money toward something your collection does not have. A spare is a tool; a duplicate is a decision about shelf space, and both deserve an honest answer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it worth buying a second copy of an out-of-print game?

Only if the game is a favorite, genuinely irreplaceable, and likely to wear out through play. Many out-of-print spares sit untouched for years. Protect the copy you have first, and consider component replacements before buying a full spare box.

How do I keep track of a game I lent out?

Write the borrower's name and the date inside the box or keep a simple list on your phone. A designated loaner copy makes the transaction easier, because both people know the stakes are lower than lending a collectible.

Should I buy a second copy for painting miniatures?

Only if you already paint regularly and the painted set is too fragile for weekly play. Most players are better served by one copy, a good storage solution, and a repair kit. A second box is a large commitment for a problem that may not appear.

Are proxies a good substitute for a second copy?

For casual play, yes, especially for a missing or worn component. Check the rules for organized play, and make sure the proxy is not distinguishable from the original during shuffling. Proxies solve component problems, not collection problems.

Does a second copy hurt resale value?

Not directly, but it doubles the amount of money tied up in one title. If the game goes out of favor, you have two boxes to sell instead of one, and expansion or duplicate listings often move slowly. Consider the exit before the purchase.

See Also